Is there a need for dedicated think tanks to shape the future of healthcare policy in New Zealand?

New Zealand’s healthcare system is internationally recognised for its strong care processes and administrative efficiency, ranking fourth out of ten countries in the Commonwealth Fund’s 2024 comparative analysis. However, issues such as inequity and access barriers highlight persistent challenges. Addressing these complex and systemic issues may require the strategic insight and innovative approaches offered by dedicated think tanks.

Think tanks are organisations that provide policy focused research and analysis to inform and influence public policy, including healthcare. They are known for their independence, interdisciplinary methods, and ability to synthesise complex data into actionable recommendations. Prominent examples include the King’s Fund in the UK and the Commonwealth Fund in the US, both of which have played pivotal roles in shaping healthcare reforms.

While NZ performs well in some healthcare domains, significant gaps remain. For instance, inequities in healthcare access and outcomes disproportionately affect Māori and Pacific populations. Addressing such disparities requires a nuanced understanding of social determinants and effective policy intervention, areas where think tanks excel through evidence-based advocacy and interdisciplinary collaboration.

Think tanks could bridge the gap between academic research and policy implementation, ensuring that healthcare policies are rooted in robust data and reflect contemporary challenges. Further, by exploring global best practices and tailoring them to local contexts, think tanks can propose creative and effective solutions to address systemic issues. They also foster public accountability by critically evaluating government policies and engaging stakeholders, from clinicians to community groups.

Critics argue that think tanks often struggle to influence policymakers directly, as political agendas and vested interests can override evidence-based recommendations. Moreover, maintaining independence is crucial and think tanks must balance funding needs with the integrity of their research.

Establishing dedicated think tanks for healthcare policy in NZ offers a compelling avenue to address pressing challenges, while strengthening the system’s overall resilience and innovation. Investing in such initiatives could ensure that we not only maintain strong international standing but also achieve equitable healthcare for all citizens.